PlantAISim

Trust

Validation & Limitations

What each status badge means, what every module was checked against, and where the tools stop being reliable.

How to read the status badges

Every calculator carries one of three badges. They describe how much checking stands behind it today, not how good the idea is.

"Validated" does not mean certified, and it does not mean tested against plant measurements. Every check listed here compares the code with a reference design calculation or a published example, so it shows the method is implemented correctly, not that it predicts a real boiler to that accuracy. A module can agree with one reference design to a few percent and still be wrong for a boiler that differs from it, so the limitations further down matter as much as the badge.

Status by module

ModuleStatusWhat it was checked against
Air Preheater Reference-based Overall U within about 0.5% of a private reference calculation.
Humid Air Thermodynamic Properties Reference-based Standard psychrometric relations and species-based transport properties.
Ash Deposit Growth Validated Checked against the author's reference workbook, including vapor diffusivities and saturation pressures.
Ash Melting Analysis — Biomass & Coal Reference-based Classical slagging and fouling indices plus a ternary phase estimate, from published methods.
Ash Melting Analysis — RDF & MSW Reference-based Same published indices, plus a worst-case screen for heavy-metal chloride systems.
Basic Combustion Validated Cross-checked against two independent published sources and an independent process-simulation workbook.
Boiler Capacity Validated Direct-method duty and efficiency checked against a reference boiler design (differences under 0.01%).
Desuperheater Preliminary Built from the enthalpy-mixing balance; not yet checked against a reference case.
Economizer Reference-based Duty within about 0.1% and overall U within about 2% of a private reference calculation; solved outlet temperature within 0.3 °C.
Emission Reference-based Published NOx, SOx and dust relations; not checked against a plant emissions record.
Electrostatic Precipitator (ESP) Reference-based Corona onset, operating voltage and current density match a reference; the migration-velocity and efficiency stage is still under review.
Evaporation Wall Chamber Reference-based Wall area and mean radiating length match the reference; duty within about 0.2%, overall U within about 5%.
Evaporator Bank — Downcomer Preliminary Same engine and defaults as the Riser; not checked against a downcomer case.
Evaporator Bank — Riser Reference-based Areas match the reference; duty within about 0.1%, overall U within about 5%.
Industrial Fan Design & Fan Curve Calculator Reference-based Standard backward-curved centrifugal fan design equations and fan-law relations.
Fixed-Bed Firing Model Reference-based Built from the author's own model and published paper; not checked against a full-scale grate.
Flue Gas Temperature Profile Reference-based Experience-based guideline ranges. This is a design choice, not a solved result.
Flue Gas Thermal Properties Validated Species heat capacities checked against a textbook source; gas radiation checked end to end against a reference workbook.
Fly Ash Particle Density and Electrical Properties — Biomass Reference-based Biomass resistivity model; results are directionally consistent with published literature but not checked against a worked case.
Fly Ash Particle Density and Electrical Properties — Coal Validated Bickelhaupt (EPRI CS-4145) correlation checked against a published worked example, within a few percent.
Fuel Data — Single Fuel Reference-based Published proximate, ultimate and ash-oxide data for common Thai biomass fuels; user-entered fuels are converted between as-received and dry bases.
Fuel Data — Mixed Fuel Blend Reference-based Mass-weighted blending of the single-fuel analyses.
Furnace Heat Transfer Reference-based Overall heat transfer coefficient within about 3% of a private reference calculation.
Radiation Heat Drop Chamber Reference-based Uses the validated Furnace engine; not separately checked against a chamber design.
Screen Tube Heat Transfer Reference-based Overall U within about 6% of a private reference calculation. The remaining gap traces to inputs in the reference, not the correlation.
Steam Drum Preliminary Built from the enthalpy and mass balance of a flash drum; not yet checked against a reference case.
Steam Table — Standard Range Validated IAPWS-IF97 industrial formulation, regions 1, 2 and 4, checked against standard published reference values (e.g. Tsat=179.886°C at 10 bar).
Steam Table — Extended Range Reference-based IAPWS-IF97 industrial formulation, regions 3 and 5.
Superheater Heat Transfer Reference-based Duty within about 0.1% and overall U within about 7% of a private reference calculation; steam outlet temperature is solved, not assumed.
Suspension Firing Boiler Reference-based Built from the author's own model; not checked against a full-scale furnace.
Thermoelectric Generator Reference-based The Ioffe maximum-efficiency equation (A.F. Ioffe, 1957) for an ideal thermoelectric leg, confirmed against multiple independent academic sources (PNAS, AIP Advances, arXiv). Material-property defaults are generic Bi₂Te₃-class order-of-magnitude values, not a specific commercial module's datasheet. Not yet checked against a published numeric worked example.
Deaerator Thermal & Mass Balance Reference-based Standard direct-contact heater energy balance using the shared IAPWS-IF97 engine. The 110–120°C standard vs up to ≈150°C elevated-pressure guidance (for acid-dew-point margin) reflects common power-plant practice; not checked against a published numeric worked example.
Deaerator Storage Tank Sizing Reference-based The 10-minute (5–30 minute practical range) retention-time guideline is drawn from American Boiler Manufacturers Association technical guidance. Vessel diameter/length from L/D ratio is a rough mechanical estimate, not a vendor-grade sizing calculation.
Deaerator NPSH & Elevation Reference-based Standard boiler-feed-pump suction design practice (e.g. Grundfos Boiler Feed Manual) — NPSHa from a saturated tank reduces to elevation minus friction loss since tank pressure and vapor pressure cancel. Not checked against a published numeric worked example.
Deaerator Droplet Heat/Mass Transfer Reference-based Whitaker's correlation (AIChE J., 1972) for droplet heating, applied as published deaerator-stripping research does; Crank's transient-diffusion-in-a-sphere solution for oxygen stripping. Known gap, disclosed on the module page: Whitaker's correlation under-represents the true condensation heat transfer rate (it omits the latent-heat effect at the droplet surface) — early experimental work (Brown, 1951) measured coefficients roughly 50× higher for comparable droplet sizes, so treat the heating-time estimate as a conservative upper bound. Spray-nozzle droplet-formation physics and tray/vessel mechanical sizing are intentionally out of scope.
Turbine Off-Design / Part-Load Reference-based Stodola's Ellipse (Cone) Law (A. Stodola, 1927; D.H. Cooke, ASME 1984) — the same method commercial plant-simulation software uses for this calculation. Checked for internal self-consistency (feeding the design point back through the solver reproduces it to 0.000000% in all three solve modes), not yet against a published numeric worked example. Assumes an infinite-stage, unchoked group.
Condensing Pressure from Cooling System Reference-based Standard Approach/Range/TTD (water-cooled) and ITD (air-cooled) power-plant cooling-system design method, with typical-value ranges drawn from published industry sources. Not yet checked against a complete published worked example the way the Turbine module was — confirm against vendor cooling-tower/ACC performance data for a real design.
Steam Turbine Expansion & Extraction Validated Checked against D.J. Dunn, Applied Thermodynamics Tutorial 1 (freestudy.co.uk), Worked Examples 3 & 5: single-stage back-pressure flow rate within 0.4% (109.05 vs 109.51 kg/s); two-stage pass-out/extraction flow rate within 2% (36.6 vs 37.34 kg/s) — the larger gap traces to the textbook's hand-drawn straight-line h-s chart approximation for the intermediate extraction enthalpy, versus this module's stage-by-stage isentropic-efficiency calculation, which is the more rigorous of the two methods.
Thermal Head Reference-based Standard Darcy-Weisbach downcomer friction and a circulation-ratio approximation, informed by published pressure-dependent CR guidelines (V. Ganapathy; Elgandelwar, Jha & Lele, 2020 — see Sources below). A screening check on circulation, not a flow solver.
Volatile Gas Combustion Reference-based Simplified global-reaction proxy for released volatile gas.

Known limitations

Sources and credits

The calculators implement published methods, and the credit belongs to their authors: Zukauskas (1972) for tube-bank cross-flow convection; Hottel-type total-emissivity methods for gas radiation, following polynomial forms in the literature; the IAPWS-IF97 industrial formulation for water and steam properties; Sutherland's law (coefficients from Crane TP-410 and the CRC Handbook) and Eucken's relation for gas transport properties; a Jakob-type friction correlation for tube-bank pressure drop; Peek-type corona onset, White's current-density relation, and Deutsch-Anderson and Matts-Ohnfeldt collection efficiency for the ESP; and the Bickelhaupt method (EPRI CS-4145) for coal fly ash resistivity. The row-count correction table for tube banks is adapted from the open-source ht library by Caleb Bell (part of the Chemical Engineering Design Library, ChEDL), released under the MIT License, reproduced below in full as required by that license. The Thermal Head module's circulation-ratio guideline range is informed by V. Ganapathy's widely-cited natural-circulation design charts (CR roughly 4–8 at high steam pressure, 15–50 at low pressure), as referenced and further developed with a similar pressure-dependent curve in A. M. Elgandelwar, R. S. Jha & M. M. Lele, "Desired Circulation Ratio for Natural Circulation in Water-Tube Boiler," International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering, Vol. 8, Issue 5, January 2020, DOI: 10.35940/ijrte.E6646.018520 — the fitted curve used on this site is our own regression against guidelines of this kind, not a reproduction of either source's exact figures. The Steam Turbine Expansion & Extraction module's isentropic-efficiency stage method and worked validation cases are drawn from D.J. Dunn, Applied Thermodynamics Tutorial 1 — Advanced Steam Cycles, freestudy.co.uk, a freely published engineering tutorial. Where a module relies on a specific paper or data set, it is cited on that module's page.

Fuel Data module — source codes

The reference fuels in the Fuel Data module each carry a short source code next to their proximate/ultimate values. Confirmed sources: entries labeled Madhiyanon or Prof. Thanit are drawn from Assoc. Prof. Dr. Thanit Medhiyanon, “Theory and Technology of Solid Fuel and Biomass Combustion” (“ทษฐีเละเทคโนโลยีการเผาไหม้เชื้อเพลิงแข็งและชีวมวล"). Rubber wood's proximate/ultimate analysis is drawn directly from the TISTR ANBOR biomass database (Thailand Institute of Scientific and Technological Research), entry #19, tested to ASTM D7582/D5373/D4239/D5865. EFE, ERI, CMU, KU and EGAT are, respectively, the short forms of the Energy for Environment Foundation, the Energy Research Institute at Chulalongkorn University, Kasetsart University, Chiang Mai University and the Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand — all real institutions that this kind of data commonly comes from in Thailand, but since the specific underlying report behind each individual table entry hasn't been traced and confirmed, those entries are now labeled Typical range rather than attributed to a specific institution, to avoid overstating how well-sourced each number is.

Ash oxide composition (SiO₂, Al₂O₃, CaO, K₂O and so on) for the fuels marked Typical range in the Ash Source field is presented as an indicative, order-of-magnitude reference rather than a traceable lab assay — ash chemistry in particular varies widely by region, soil and plant variety, so a specific named source for this field would overstate its precision. Use your own tested ash analysis for any real design decision; the TISTR ANBOR database is a free starting point for Thailand-representative proximate/ultimate data, though it does not currently publish detailed ash oxide breakdowns.

MIT License text

MIT License Copyright (C) 2016-2025, Caleb Bell <[email protected]> and Contributors Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions: The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE.

Source: github.com/CalebBell/ht. Only the row-correction table is used here; PlantAISim's own calculators are original code and not part of the ht package.

Before relying on a result

Compare it with supplier data or an independent calculation, and have a qualified engineer review anything that affects safety, guarantees or purchasing. See also the Terms & Disclaimer.

Found a difference from your own data or a reference? Email [email protected]. Corrections are how this page improves.